LENTIL
A Regina Community Research Project
Research Methodology

How We Identify Food Deserts

Our methodology combines geographic accessibility analysis with socioeconomic indicators, adapting the peer-reviewed approach developed by Huda et al. (2025) for Mississauga, Ontario to the Regina, Saskatchewan context.

Network AnalysisGIS Spatial AnalysisSocioeconomic IndicatorsCensus 2021 Data

Definition of a Food Desert

A food desert is a residential area that meets two criteria:

  1. 1Geographic Inaccessibility: The area is beyond a 15-minute walking distance from any grocery store that provides fresh, nutritious food options.
  2. 2Socioeconomic Deprivation: The area falls within the most deprived quintile (Q5) by at least one of three socioeconomic indicators.

Geographic Boundaries

City BoundaryCity of Regina Open Data
Dissemination AreasStatistics Canada 2021
Zoning/Land UseCity of Regina Open Data
Road NetworkOpenStreetMap

Socioeconomic Indicators

Median Household IncomeCensus 2021

Q5 = lowest 20% income (most deprived)

MSDIINSPQ

Material & Social Deprivation Index. Q5 = highest material deprivation

CIMDStatistics Canada

Canadian Index of Multiple Deprivation. Q5 = highest economic dependency

Grocery Store Locations

Compiled from the Regina Qu'Appelle Health Region (RQHR) Food Asset Map, geocoded using the City of Regina ArcGIS Geocoder. Stores are classified by category rather than NAICS codes (which were unavailable for Saskatchewan businesses).

Included (~28 stores)
  • • Grocery Store
  • • Grocery Store with Delivery

Full-service retailers offering fresh produce and nutritious food options

Excluded
  • Specialty & Small Grocers

    Halal, Cultural, Small Grocery Stores — often higher-priced and specialize in products for specific communities rather than general grocery needs

  • Food Programs

    REACH Good Food Box, Community Food Pantries — not retail locations

  • Seasonal Markets

    Farmers' Markets — limited operating hours and days restrict reliable access

Note: The original Mississauga study used NAICS codes from a business directory. NAICS data is not available for Saskatchewan in Statistics Canada's Open Database of Businesses.

1

Network Analysis: Isochrone Generation

For each validated grocery store, we generate a 15-minute walking isochrone using the Valhalla routing engine. This creates a polygon representing all areas reachable within a 15-minute walk, accounting for actual road networks, sidewalks, and pedestrian paths.

{
  "locations": [{"lon": -104.6189, "lat": 50.4452}],
  "costing": "pedestrian",
  "contours": [{"time": 15}],
  "polygons": true
}
2

Create Unified Walkable Area

All individual store isochrones are merged (unioned) into a single walkable area geometry. This represents all residential areas within 15 minutes of any grocery store.

3

Identify Geographic Food Deserts

Geographic Food Deserts (GFDs) are calculated by subtracting the walkable area from residential zones:

GFD = Residential_Areas − Walkable_Area

Only residential zones (from City of Regina zoning data) are considered. Industrial and commercial areas are excluded because no one lives there.

4

Calculate Local Quintiles

Socioeconomic quintiles are calculated locally within Regina DAsrather than using provincial data. This ensures we identify relative deprivation within the city context, with approximately 20% of DAs in each quintile.

Income
High → Q1, Low → Q5
MSDI
Low → Q1, High → Q5
CIMD
Low → Q1, High → Q5
5

Identify Food Deserts

Food deserts are identified by intersecting the Geographic Food Desert layer with DA polygons in the most deprived quintile (Q5) for each indicator:

Income: FD = GFD ∩ DAs where income_quintile = 5
MSDI: FD = GFD ∩ DAs where msdi_quintile = 5
CIMD: FD = GFD ∩ DAs where cimd_quintile = 5
Composite: FD = GFD ∩ DAs where ALL THREE = Q5

Regina Context

Prior Research

Earlier research using a more conservative 750-metre walking threshold found significant disparities in grocery access across Regina neighbourhoods, with roughly one in four having no walkable food access at all. While methodologies differ, the concentration of food retail in specific areas of the city remains a persistent structural feature.

Source: Sask Trends Monitor (2012), cited in Qualman et al. (2013)

A Note on Scope

This analysis focuses on retail grocery access within the conventional food system. It does not capture access to traditional Indigenous foods, which are typically distributed through informal networks—family connections, sharing, and travel to traditional territories—rather than retail channels. A 2013 environmental scan noted a “nearly unbroken horizon of research gaps” regarding Indigenous food access in Canadian cities. With approximately 10% of Regina's population identifying as Indigenous, this represents a significant dimension of food security that warrants dedicated future research.

Context drawn from: Qualman, D., Sanden, T., Desmarais, A.A., Marsden, D. & Hansen, Y. (2013). Environmental Scan: Conventional & Indigenous Food Systems and Gaps in the Regina Area, SK. Regina, Saskatchewan.

Limitations & Considerations

Winter Conditions

Regina's harsh winters with snow, ice, and extreme cold significantly reduce practical walking distances for many residents. A 10-minute walking threshold may be more appropriate during winter months than the 15-minute standard used here.

Walking Distance Only

Low-income residents often lack access to vehicles, and public transit adds time and cost. Walking distance is particularly important for these households, making the 15-minute threshold a meaningful but conservative measure.

Temporal Snapshot

Census data (2021) and grocery locations represent point-in-time snapshots. Conditions may have changed.

Census Data Limitations

Census data is collected via 25% sample and aggregated to DA level, so it may not reflect individual households.

Conventional Food System Only

This analysis covers retail grocery access. It does not capture traditional Indigenous food systems, which operate through informal sharing networks rather than retail channels.

Boundary Effects

Grocery stores just outside Regina's boundary that serve edge neighborhoods are not included.

Based On

Huda, T., Wang, A., Zhang, H., Guo, L., Zhang, T., & Huang, Y. (2025). Identifying food deserts in Mississauga: A comparative analysis of socioeconomic indicators. Urban Science, 9(7), 265.

View original paper

Explore the data yourself

Use our interactive map to explore food deserts in Regina, check your address, and see how different indicators reveal different patterns.

Open Interactive Map →